Communities around the state of Massachusetts, and likely the nation itself, are reaching a critical mass when it comes to funding their operations. Cities and towns are literally running out of money; tax collection isn’t even close to the amount of money that is needed to run governments given the increases in wages, benefits and fuel just to name a few.
Just the same many taxpayers are saying “No” to requests for Proposition 2 1/2 tax overrides. Most recently the Town of Freetown turned down eight requests for overrides and now the town is in a quandry as to how it will continue to operate as fiscal year 2009 rolls on. The sad part of this vote, is that a mere 30% of registered voters have seemingly spoken for all the registered voters in Freetown. How do we allow 30% to speak for the wishes of 70%? Votes are somewhat more important and should not be satisfied with what is essentially representative sampling of a larger demographic.
The crux of the matter appears to be that taxpayers are feeling the pinch all over. Many are depressed from the current state of the economy. Unlike Phil Gramm’s statement that we are in a “mental recession”, many families are truly feeling the pinch of a honest-to-goodness recession; mortgage payments are high from the recent housing price spike which encouraged a lot of borrowing and refinancing, then there are car payments, school loans, and all the daily basics like utilities, food, entertainment, clothing and the list goes on and on. This is an extremely bad time to ask taxpayers for more money – regardless of the reason. The truth is that most people aren’t listening to the reasons, but rather they are listening to their pocketbooks and wallets – and they’re hearing “You can’t afford it!”
The trouble with a decision like this one, is that it potentially fuels the movement of a growing number of people who might just be willing to support elimination of the state income tax. A similar measure gained 49% of the vote a few years ago, and it will be back on the ballot in November. Elimination of the state’s income tax would be disastrous at a time when the Patrick administration is trying to repair a lot of damage left behind by Mitt Romney and his Republican predecessors over the past sixteen years. A complete elimination of the state’s income tax, would likely require legislative intervention to prevent a total collapse of the state’s fiscal infrastructure.
People think it’s bad now, just wait and see what happens when the state has no money at all.
The irony with the decision in Freetown, is that for a savings of $175 per taxpayer, the voters were willing to uphold 12 layoffs at the Elementary school, 2 in the police department, 1 at the library, reduce hours at various town offices, eliminate firefighter training, and force the 911 center to use part-time employees to fill a vacancy. These ill-considered votes directly affect the town’s capacity to provide for the education, well-being and safety of all town residents; it boggles the mind how voters can rationalize trading all of this for $175 a year in extra taxes – maybe that elementary school is more important than we think!